20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

by Lori Deschene
In my last blog post I talked about hoarding—compulsively collecting and saving an assortment of useless stuff. Maybe you went through your things and decided to donate some and toss the rest. Or perhaps you only pretended to de-clutter, all the while visualizing yourself running hand-in-hand with your Atari to the tune of “Looks Like We Made It.” So that got me thinking: is asking a pack rat to minimize like demanding sight from the blind? How can you simplify your space if you’re operating with a poorly tuned useful vs. useless compass?
I think I have the solution, or at the very least a distraction from work. Here are 20 signs you don't need something:
 
20. You use the word “someday” to describe it—as in “someday I may want to practice make-up application using that mannequin head I found in my aunt’s attic.”
 
19. You forgot you owned it for more than a month, and remembering doesn’t evoke any type of emotional response (beyond generic statements, such as “I like it” or “I need it.”)
 
18. If you had a yard sale and someone offered $20 for it, you’d hand it over in a heartbeat.
 
17. If your friend gave it to you as a Christmas gift you’d make a mental note along the lines of “Give Lisa alphabet magnets and socks next year.”
 
16. If your friends asked you why you have it you’d turn into Deepak Chopra, saying something like, “We are all connected. You, me, that orange hobby horse.”
 
15. Its broken or, even worse, obsolete (i.e.: your old car phone).
 
14. If you decided to spend a year traveling you wouldn’t consider bringing it with you.
 
13. If you had to spend $20 every month maintaining it, you’d decide it isn’t worth it.
 
12. You’d admit it may be someone else’s trash, but have no justification for it being your treasure.
 
11. You cannot complete this sentence with an action verb: “I will use this to…”
 
10. If your child accidentally damaged it, your knee jerk reaction would be “I didn’t really need it anyway.”
 
9.  It hurts to think about it: Your ex-boyfriend gave it to you. Your mother-in-law said you need it, but you disagree. You fit in it before your love affair with curly fries.
 
8. You got it from someone else and admit you’d never spend money your own money on it.
 
7. The Salvation Army might say no if you tried to donate it.
 
6. If you asked your mother’s opinion about keeping it, she might say something like, “Well, what do you think? That’s all that really matters!”
 
5. It smells like moth balls because it rarely sees the light of day.
 
4. Learning how to use it would take more time than you will ever devote. (And be honest—do you really think metal casting is your thing?)
 
3. You’re keeping it out of guilt—it’s still new in the box; it looks like something a smart person would appreciate; it’s a classic 500-page book you should have read freshman year in college.
 
2. You keep saying it could be valuable one day—but who are you kidding. You never want anyone else to have it!
 
1. You would never clutch it and say “My precious” in a gesture of playful self-mocking. (Assume you’re the kind of person who goes to medieval fairs and quotes Lord of the Rings.)
 
If it’s not valuable, meaningful, or important to your life, either trash it or give it away. If it does serve a purpose, get the most from it. (Shameless self-promotion: we list hundreds of product tips and tricks right here!)
Know any other signs? Add them to the list! Or if you have something that doesn’t pass the 20-signs-test but you still want to keep it, let me know. I’m fascinated by the way we attach to things. Please excuse me while I go braid the hair on my life-size My Little Pony.

posted @ Tuesday, September 16, 2008 4:35 PM

Print

Comments on this entry:

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Scott @ The Passive Dad at 9/17/2008 10:35 AM
Gravatar
I'm laughing at #7 because I've had the Salvation army say no to a donation. I dropped of a ton of "useful" baby toys and the collection lady told me they don't accept used toys. Ugh! back to the garage they went.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Lori at 9/17/2008 11:38 AM
Gravatar
I've had that experience, too! I used to live across the street from low-income housing in SF. Oftentimes I'd put boxes of stuff out front with the label "free." People always took them!

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by rjleaman at 9/17/2008 12:53 PM
Gravatar
I can't tell you how profoundly relieved I am to read Scott the Passive Dad's comment, above, and know that I'm not alone here with #7...

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Thomas Hayfield at 9/17/2008 1:15 PM
Gravatar
Hay u, I have a similar set of criteria I say to myself and then often ignore. My final judgment on stuff is do I have space. That ends the wondering and pondering.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Thomas Johnson at 9/17/2008 3:34 PM
Gravatar
My sign that I had too much stuff:

After a month of travelling with a single large backpack, I returned home and just thought - why do I have all this stuff?

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Lori at 9/17/2008 3:45 PM
Gravatar
Hey Thomas~

That's exactly what made me think. I used to work on marketing tours, spending a few months at a time traveling. After 6 tours I wondered why I had a bunch of crap in boxes I didn't miss for well over a year!

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Laurel Plum at 9/17/2008 4:50 PM
Gravatar
Fun list! Except #6. No way would I ask my mother. Love her heart, she is the kind that would be able to list numerous uses and ask about it every time she saw you thereafter. LOL.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Mike King at 9/17/2008 5:10 PM
Gravatar
Laughed out loud from #20, and #7. Love those and great funny list by the way!

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Kimberlee at 9/17/2008 6:09 PM
Gravatar
These tips are great! My personal one is "Would I pay to move this?" If no, out it goes. The bad thing is I tried this technique before I moved a few months ago, and I still have boxes of things I haven't unpacked. *Sigh.* Time to purge my stuff again.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by MJ at 9/17/2008 7:09 PM
Gravatar
If the item is questionable... I ask myself "how much would it cost to replace it, if I ever need another one?" If the answer is something I am willing to pay or if it is unlikely I will ever need one again, I get rid of it, rather than take up my precious space for another X amount of time.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Donna at 9/17/2008 8:34 PM
Gravatar
I moved and downsized within the last month.
I sold a lot of things @ l0 cents on the dollar and
and also had a Goodwill turn away an offer of a
very good item. Who knows? One persons
treasure ..........

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Lori at 9/18/2008 9:48 AM
Gravatar
Laurel~
Your mother sounds like my grandmother. We call her MacGyver because she can do all kinds of things with all kinds of things.

Kimberlee & MJ~
Great ideas! Thanks for adding to the list :)

Donna~
I think it's great if you can get a little money back and also give something to someone who can use it better.

For the longest time I had a thigh master under my bed (you know...Suzanne Sommers exercise/torture device). Who was I kidding. I was never going to master my thighs and I knew it. Then this teenage girl snagged it at a yard sale for a buck. She looked so excited to find it, like she really might pull it out during commercial breaks. Gave me a warm-fuzzy-saving-the-world-one-leg-at-a-time feeling :)

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Suzie Cheel at 9/18/2008 9:10 PM
Gravatar
Love Kimberlee's comment " would I pay to move this!"

I have moved stuff and then trown it out! eek

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Elvera at 9/19/2008 6:38 PM
Gravatar
Love these- some are serious and some I just had to Laugh at. :)

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Brian Patrie at 9/20/2008 8:45 PM
Gravatar
I confess that my small collection of obsolete computers (including some that most people never heard of) doesn't pass this test.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by IwantAdirigible at 9/21/2008 9:51 PM
Gravatar
One thing - Let's say I throw out the old stuff in my freezer. From then on when I look at things in the store I'll think, "I have room for that in my freezer." I'll also think (and this is true) "it's easier to keep a full freezer cold." That's because if the freezer isn't full, every time I open it the cold air easily gets sucked out and replaced with warm air which then needs to be heated whereas an object just sits there staying cold.

The final result is that after cleaning the freezer out, I feel pressure to fill it with new junk. I become more careless in my purchases. I end up with new junk and less money. The same is true with other collections of junk. Suddenly the room looks "empty".

Then there's the whole what happens to my junk thing. Things that are thrown out tend to end up in the ocean or in the air after burning. It's better ecologically to not buy things but then look at how stores are designed. They're enormous. You have to walk by tons of things you don't need to get to the item you do need and usually the item you do need isn't very good anyway. It's a huge plot to keep you buying stuff.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Mel at 9/23/2008 2:56 PM
Gravatar
I often give away stuff on Freecycle. You can find a Yahoo! group for your area and swap stuff. It's wonderful. The best part: all you have to do is post it, pick who gets to have it, stick it on your front porch, and it disappears! Knowing it's going to someone who wants it really helps me let go of things.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by octamom at 10/2/2008 6:13 PM
Gravatar
What a fun site! Glad to have stumbledupon you! I just posted at my place yesterday about my mysterious collection of toilet bowl cleaners! Had to laugh when I saw this site come up today!
Blessings!~

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Ryan G at 10/7/2008 2:26 PM
Gravatar
Funny. Thanks.

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Holly at 10/12/2008 4:38 PM
Gravatar
I love this, I have a sister that keeps everything, she gets is from our dad. I will have to send this link over to her, maybe she will get the clue

# re: 20 Signs You Really Don't Need That Thing

Left by Becca at 10/12/2008 5:57 PM
Gravatar
This is great! I am going to have to send it off to my mother! She keeps EVERYTHING!

# aalujilc

Left by aalujilc at 3/14/2009 5:29 AM
Gravatar
aalujilc

Your comment:



 (will not be displayed)


 
 
 
Please add 3 and 3 and type the answer here:
 

Live Comment Preview: